For most small businesses, Microsoft 365 is where everything lives: email, files, calendars, Teams chats and the accounts people sign in with. That makes it the first thing an attacker goes for. The good news is that Microsoft 365 has strong security built in. The catch is that much of it depends on settings, and a tenant set up quickly by whoever was available at the time rarely has them right. This post covers the eight settings worth checking first, what each one does, and why it matters.
Why Microsoft 365 is the target
Most attacks on small firms do not involve clever hacking. Someone receives a convincing email, types their password into a fake Microsoft sign-in page, and the attacker signs in as them. From there they can read the mailbox, set up a rule that quietly forwards every email to an outside address, and wait for an invoice to arrive so they can send a copy with their own bank details. Each of the settings below breaks a step in that chain.
1. Turn on multi-factor authentication for everyone
Multi-factor authentication, usually a prompt in the Microsoft Authenticator app, means a stolen password is not enough on its own. It should be on for every account, not just the directors. Small tenants without advanced licences can switch on Security Defaults in the Microsoft Entra admin centre, which turns on multi-factor authentication for all users at no extra cost. Tenants on Microsoft 365 Business Premium can use Conditional Access instead, which gives finer control. Cyber Essentials requires multi-factor authentication on cloud services wherever it is available, so this one is not optional if you hold or want the certificate.
2. Block legacy sign-in methods
Older email protocols, such as basic authentication over POP and IMAP, cannot ask for a second factor, so attackers use them to get round it. Security Defaults blocks them. If you use Conditional Access, add a policy that does the same. Check first that nothing in the office still relies on them, such as an old scanner that emails documents.
3. Keep admin accounts separate and few
Nobody should read email or browse the web on an account with Global Administrator rights. Give admin rights to a separate account used only for administration, protected with multi-factor authentication. Microsoft recommends fewer than five Global Administrators, with at least two so you are never locked out. In many small firms every director is a Global Administrator on their everyday account, which means one phished inbox hands over the whole tenant.
4. Stop automatic forwarding to outside addresses
A forwarding rule that sends a copy of every email to an outside address is one of the first things an attacker sets up, because it keeps working after the password is changed. Check that automatic external forwarding is blocked in the outbound spam policy in the Microsoft Defender portal, and look through existing mailbox rules for anything forwarding outside the business. If someone genuinely needs it, allow it for that mailbox only.
5. Rein in file sharing
SharePoint and OneDrive can create Anyone links, which open a file for whoever has the link, with no sign-in. Over a few years these build up, and nobody remembers what is out there. In the SharePoint admin centre, consider limiting sharing to new and existing guests, or to people in your organisation, and set links to expire. This matters even more if you use or plan to use Copilot, because Copilot can show each person anything their permissions allow them to open.
6. Protect your domain with DKIM and DMARC
SPF, DKIM and DMARC are DNS records that tell other mail servers which email genuinely comes from your domain. Without them, it is easy for criminals to send email that looks like it came from you, to your clients and suppliers. Turn on DKIM signing for your own domain in the Microsoft Defender portal, publish a DMARC record, and move it towards a policy of quarantine or reject once you are sure your legitimate email passes. You can check where your domain stands today with the five checks in our earlier post.
7. Make sure audit logging is on
If something does go wrong, the audit log is how you find out what happened: who signed in from where, which rules were created, which files were opened. It is on by default in most tenants, but it is worth confirming in the Microsoft Purview portal. Without it, an investigation starts with no evidence.
8. Stop forcing regular password changes
This one surprises people. The National Cyber Security Centre and Microsoft both advise against forcing passwords to expire every few months, because it pushes people towards weak, predictable passwords with a number on the end. A long password, multi-factor authentication and a change only when there is reason to think it has been exposed is the better approach. Check the password expiry policy in the Microsoft 365 admin centre and set passwords not to expire.
What this means for Cyber Essentials
Several of these settings map straight onto the Cyber Essentials controls. Multi-factor authentication on cloud services and separate admin accounts fall under user access control. Blocking legacy sign-in and tightening sharing fall under secure configuration. If you are preparing for the scheme, getting Microsoft 365 right covers a large part of the work, and the assessor will ask about it.
Is this a big job?
For a tenant of ten or twenty users, the settings themselves can usually be changed in an afternoon. The time goes on checking that nothing breaks: the old scanner, the shared mailbox someone signs into directly, the supplier who receives forwarded invoices. Make changes one at a time, tell staff what to expect before multi-factor authentication goes on, and keep a note of what you changed and why.
If you would rather it was done for you, our Microsoft 365 and Google Workspace service sets up and administers the tenant to a security baseline that covers everything above, and our Managed IT Support keeps it that way day to day.



